Can you build an ADU on your lot? Utah law splits that question in two, and most people do not know there are two answers. An internal ADU, built inside the walls of the house you already live in, is protected by state law and your city has to allow it in residential zones. A detached ADU, a separate building in the yard, is not covered by that law at all and is entirely up to your city. Those two projects get the same three letters and they live under completely different rules.

The internal ADU, and why the state stepped in
Utah’s internal ADU statute says that in areas zoned primarily for residential use, an internal accessory dwelling unit is a permitted use. Not a conditional use. Not something you argue for at a public hearing. Permitted.
An internal ADU means a dwelling created inside the footprint of the primary house as it exists at the time, in a detached single family home that the owner of record occupies as their primary residence, rented for 30 consecutive days or longer.
For that one unit, the statute says a city may not restrict its size relative to the primary dwelling, the total lot size, the street frontage, or whether it connects internally to the rest of the house. Architectural rules have to be the same ones applied to any single family home.
That is a significant amount of protection, and it is the single most useful thing a Cache Valley homeowner can know before calling anybody.
What your city can still require
The statute leaves plenty in the city’s hands. They can require compliance with building, health and fire codes, and they will. They can require the house to still look like a single family home from the street. They can require one additional on site parking space, unless the ordinance already demands four. If you build the unit into a garage and the space becomes habitable, they can make you replace that parking. And they can require a permit or license to rent it.
What your city can prohibit outright
This is the list worth reading twice, because any one of these can end the conversation.
A separate utility meter. An ADU in a mobile home. An ADU where the primary dwelling is on a failing septic tank. Rentals shorter than 30 days. Rentals where the house is not the owner’s primary residence. An ADU on a lot of 6,000 square feet or less. And ADUs inside a zoning district that covers 25 percent or less of the residentially zoned land in the city, which is the carve out cities use to keep certain neighborhoods out of it.
That lot size line catches people. If your lot is 6,000 square feet or under, your city is allowed to say no, and some do.
The detached ADU is a different world
None of the above applies to a separate building in your back yard. The internal ADU statute does not cover detached units, so whether you can build one, how big, how tall, how far from the fence, how many parking stalls, and whether you need a conditional use permit are all decided by your city’s own ordinance.
Cache Valley cities are not consistent with each other on this, and several have changed their rules in the last two years. Logan, North Logan, Providence, Smithfield, Hyrum and Nibley each handle it their own way, and a neighbor’s experience in a different city tells you nothing about yours.
What counts as an ADU, and what does not
The line is a kitchen.
A finished basement with a bedroom, a bathroom and a living area is a finished basement. Add cooking facilities and a separate entrance and you have created a second dwelling unit, which is a different thing legally, and it is the point at which permits, inspections, parking and rental licensing all attach.
A guest room over the garage with no kitchen is not an ADU. A mother in law suite with its own kitchen is. A detached shop with a bathroom and a sink is not, until somebody puts a range in it.
This matters because people build the second thing while thinking they built the first, and then find out at an appraisal, a refinance or a sale.
Nobody can answer this on the phone
I want to be straight about this, because it is the question I get asked first and it is the one I cannot shortcut.
There is nothing you could tell me in a two minute call that would let me say yes or no with any confidence. It depends on your city, your zoning district, your lot size, your septic or sewer situation, whether the house is your primary residence, and in the detached case on an ordinance that may have been rewritten since the last time I read it.
What I can do is tell you which of the two projects you are actually asking about, which decides everything that follows, and then point you at the right counter.
What to ask your city, in this order
Call the planning or community development office and ask these.
Is my property in a zoning district where internal ADUs are permitted, or is it inside the excluded area? What is my lot size on your records, and does it clear your minimum? Do you allow detached ADUs in my zone, and is it permitted by right or conditional? How many additional parking stalls do you require? Do you require a rental license, and what does it cost? Is there an owner occupancy requirement and how is it enforced?
Write the answers down with the date and the name of whoever told you. Ordinances change, and the person who answers in March may give a different answer than the one who answered in October.
This is general information rather than legal advice, and your city’s current ordinance governs over anything written here.
Once you know the answer
If it is an internal ADU, you are looking at a project much closer to a basement finish than to new construction, and the basement finishing cost guide is the better reference for what it costs.
If it is detached, you are looking at a ground up build with excavation, a foundation and a full shell, which puts it in the range covered by the ADU cost guide. Our published figures run $75,000 to $170,000 for a garage or basement conversion and $150,000 to $400,000 or more for a detached unit.
For the permitting side specifically, see what permits you need to build an ADU in Cache Valley, and attached versus detached covers the trade off once you know both are on the table. To talk through a specific property in Logan, North Logan, Providence, Smithfield or anywhere in Cache Valley, request an estimate.


